Search for...

Cracking the Code: The Art of Valuing a Startup Beyond Storytelling

how to value a startup

Valuing a startup is an important task that founders must do to attract investors and determine the worth of the company. While a pitch deck can sometimes convince investors through an innovative idea, the people behind it, and market potential, nothing is more convincing than expressing the value in monetary terms. So how founders deal with the process of valuing a startup when storytelling is not enough, and how do the dynamics between founders and investors look like? Whether you’re a budding entrepreneur or an investor, understanding how to value a startup is necessary for making informed decisions.

Unlike established companies with track records, valuing a startup poses unique challenges. In fact, at a very early stage valuing a startup is also somehow storytelling, debate, and posturing than relying solely on mathematical calculations. 

The main reason is that the intangible nature of startup results in difficulty in assigning a value to it. Startups usually don’t make money, and their track record is not solid enough to forecast confidently. It makes storytelling quite an essential aspect in shaping the perception of a startup’s value. 

Numbers and financial projections do not solely drive investors but are also captivated by a compelling narrative that paints a picture of future success. When that’s the case, founders often defend their valuation by emphasizing the strength of their team, existing content, and potential for revenue generation. It all shows how defining a realistic value is always highly relative. 

The role of market perception in determining the value of a startup is something that founders need to be aware of. The valuation goes with how investors and the broader market perceive their startups. Building a solid brand, demonstrating market demand, and showcasing unique differentiators can positively influence the perceived value of the startup.

Establishing a valuation cap in the current funding round is a good practice influencing future financing rounds. The founders consider how subsequent investors might perceive the startup’s value and how the valuation cap protects earlier investors from excessive dilution. This forward-looking perspective demonstrates the long-term implications of valuation decisions. The valuation cap determines the maximum value at which the startup can be priced in future rounds.

Read more:  5 Lessons for Startup Teams from Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3

When deciding the cap value, founders should consider factors such as industry benchmarks, advice from experienced individuals, and their confidence in the company’s growth potential. With the above factors taken together, they all should be transformed into a story around monetary value. In this sense, the valuation cap becomes part of the storytelling process that portrays the startup as a high-growth venture. And it also evolves a key point of negotiation between founders and investors, reflecting the potential growth and risk associated with the startup.

Such a temptation of founders to create as high valuations as possible creates a startup valuation bubble. What pushes founders to do so may be a lack of fear among a generation of investors who haven’t experienced previous market crashes and an increasing demand for exciting returns. Still, for many investors, even if the valuation is higher than ideal when the investment remains relatively small, they may take a risk and aim for the potential for high returns in the startup world. Understanding the dynamics of the startup valuation bubble is crucial for both founders and investors. But all in all, it is just a subject of the negotiations and seems proper until both parties agree.

So founders generally prefer a higher valuation cap because it allows them to raise more capital in future funding rounds without diluting their ownership significantly. A higher valuation cap implies a more significant potential for future growth, attracting more investors and signaling confidence in the company’s ability to achieve higher valuations in subsequent rounds.

On the other hand, investors often prefer a lower valuation cap as it allows them to obtain a larger ownership stake in the startup for a relatively smaller investment. A lower valuation cap reduces the risk of overpaying for the company and potentially losing returns.

Startup valuation seems much easier when the founders and investors recognize that the valuation is an educated guess based on limited data and numerous assumptions. This understanding of uncertainty underscores the importance of continuous evaluation and adaptation as the startup progresses.

Read more:  SaaS Business Models: VC Perspective on Building a Successful Subscription Business in CEE

Instead of being just a mathematical concept, valuing a startup is a much more complex process that involves storytelling, negotiation, market dynamics, and investor perspectives. Startup founders and investors can make more informed decisions by understanding the nuances of startup valuation, leading to successful partnerships and sustainable growth. 

By considering factors such as industry benchmarks, team strength, revenue potential, and market conditions, founders can reach a compelling valuation for their startups. Likewise, investors can assess a particular valuation’s risks and growth potential. Understanding how to value a startup is a skill that can greatly impact the success and sustainability of a company in the ever-evolving entrepreneurial landscape.


Help us grow the emerging innovation hubs in Central and Eastern Europe

Every single contribution of yours helps us guarantee our independence and sustainable future. With your financial support, we can keep on providing constructive reporting on the developments in the region, give even more global visibility to our ecosystem, and educate the next generation of innovation journalists and content creators.

Find out more about how your donation could help us shape the story of the CEE entrepreneurial ecosystem!

One-time donation

You can also support The Recursive’s mission with a pick-any-amount, one-time donation. 👍

Pawel Poltorak is an experienced CMO and Strategic Advisor in the tech sector, driven by a passion to help founders, entrepreneurs, and investors to succeed. As an author, he explores and writes on CEE startups and new technology through the lenses of marketing, economics, sociology, and geopolitics.